Defining and Defending Truth

shutterstock_569973988
The issue of being truthful or not has repeatedly been in the national news over these past few months and that is a good thing. It brings to our attention the importance of some fundamental values in our society such as honesty, integrity and truthfulness. The national discussion also gives us a vertiginous glimpse of the abyss we would fall into if we abandoned those values.
However, defining the concept of truth is difficult. Scholars, philosophers, and theologians have struggle with its meaning for ages. The concept has been explored in literature and the arts.
The German 20th century philosopher Martin Heidegger believed that the ancient Greek word for truth simply meant “the revealing of something that was previously concealed.” Another German philosopher, Jurgen Habermas believed that truth is whatever is agreed upon (the Consensus Theory.) The poet John Keats made the connection between truth and beauty. He wrote in Ode on a Grecian Urn:
“’Beauty is truth, truth beauty,’ – that is all / Ye know on earth, and all ye need to know.”
In this complicated process of defining truth, we find some comfort from “facts.” However, we quasi never have all the facts. Furthermore, there is a difference between facts and how we interpret or experience them. A good analogy is the wind chill factor. It is the difference between the outdoor temperature that is scientifically measured and what we feel or experience because of the cooling effect of wind.
We all tend to believe what confirms an opinion we already have. Professor Philip Fernbach of the University of Colorado and Professor Steven Sloman of Brown University in a recent New York Times Op-ed “Why We believe Obvious Untruth” make the interesting point that often we do not have enough knowledge to separate fact from fiction because; they write, “ignorance is our natural state; it is a product of the way the mind works.” They also note that “large group of people can coalesce around a common belief when few of them individually possess the requisite knowledge to support it.”
How should we then live? How can we act in a rational and moral way if we are confused as to what is and what is not? Are we prisoners of our own ignorance as to the truth? We all know the famous biblical saying:
“Ye shall know the truth and the truth shall set you free.”
  • I believe we should rely on what we believe is true while honestly challenging our beliefs to make sure they correspond to reality, or at least to the reality we perceive.
  • We should never engage in any activity that we know is deceptive and make every effort not to intentionally mislead by what we do, say or write.
  • Finally, we should hold accountable any individual, corporation or government that engages in deceptive practices.
The PRSA Code of Ethics states that:
“We adhere to the highest standards of accuracy and truth in advancing the interests of those we represent and in communicating with the public.”
The reason truth is so important is that when it is betrayed, it erodes and sometimes permanently damages trust. We cannot function without a minimum of trust. Without trust we would never undergo surgery or take a prescription drug or even buy food. Without trust we would never ride an elevator or a car or even sit on a chair. The list is endless. It is, in fact, hard to imagine a human activity that does not involve at least some level of trust.
That is why it is critical for democratic societies to defend the truth whenever it is threatened.
As Martin Luther once said:
Peace maybe, but Truth at all cost.

Previously published by PRSA-NY

Emmanuel Tchividjian
Principal
The Markus Gabriel Group


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Image
Patriotism Today The current “Anthem” protests controversy should hopefully lead to a national conversation as to the meaning of patriotism.   What does it mean to be patriotic today, in a very divided society with sometimes opposing views of America’s core values and what it stands for? Patriotism is perceived as a positive concept and attitude sustained by strong emotions such as love, belonging, gratitude and pride. A position or an attitude perceived as un-patriotic is considered by some as a form of treason that deserves punishment.  According the U.S. Constitution (Article III, Section 3) “Congress shall have the power to declare the punishment of treason.” Patriotism can be misused or even abused if wrongly applied. John Kleinig, Emeritus Professor of Philosophy in the Department of Criminal Justice, John Jay College of Criminal Justice, the co-author of The Ethics of Patriotism , makes the point that patriotism might be conceived as ...
Read more
Image
The Ethics of Silence and of Speaking Up The virtues of silence have long been recognized. The popular saying “speech is silver but silence is golden” may date back to ancient Egypt. It probably means that in some circumstances the less you say the better it is. I can imagine that when you are in the company of strangers, discretion would be more appropriate than indiscretion. Keeping a secret can be a form of silence that is highly ethical. Silence in some cases is a legal right. If you are being arrested, you do have “the right to remain silent.” The Fifth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution permits you not to answer specific questions when you may, by the answers given, incriminate yourself. Sometimes silence is an obligation as when its purpose is not to disturb the tranquility of others such as in the library or the Amtrak silence car. I am afraid I was oblivious to that obligation last week as I boarded an Amtrak train on my way to Annapolis, Md., to speak t...
Read more
Image
Your Humble Servant, The CEO The term “leadership” is relatively new. According to the Oxford English Dictionary, the word can be traced only as far back as the 19 th century. Today, leadership has become a hot topic. Amazon offers 300,000 books with the word “leadership” in the title. It seems that most everyone wants to be a leader or at least be perceived as one. The leadership status carries panache and demands respect and undoubtedly satisfies one’s ego. The most frequent question asked when discussing leadership is whether leaders are born or made? The consensus today is that there are indeed some in-born characteristics that predisposes people to become leaders. A recent research by the University of Illinois suggests that leadership is 30 % genetic and 70 % lessons learned by life experiences. I was awakened to the possibility that I might have some leadership qualities by an incident in my teens. I was in the English Church in Lausanne, Switzerl...
Read more